Best way of Recruitment: Headhunters/ Placement Consultants or Job Portals

ign="center">can never have any output for employer) + Costs of
Here we evaluate the Efficiency and Costtraining + Opportunity lost+ cost of new
Effectiveness of using Job Portals as RecruitmentRecruitment+ Client/business/systems stolen away
Tool as against hiring through Placement Consultants/etc).
Executive Search Firms.5) Cost of extra Attrition: When a Company uses
These days there is a growing trend of CompaniesJob Portals internally majority of its employees
opting for Job Portals for their Internal Hiring in orderknows it and are marketed an idea of floating their
to reduce costs instead of approaching Headhunters/resume on a Jobsite even if they are not looking for
Placement Services. Job Portals by way of their Hugea Change. The moment they put their resume on
Database Access and Job Posting Options Offer ajobsites, lot of calls/offers start coming back to
seemingly very attractive and cost effective way tothem. This would lead to some additional stable
hiring. Is it the best and cheapest method? Letspeople leaving the organization. Cost may
revaluate the Costs involved in such Hiring (for say aconservatively again be say Rs 5 – 10 Lacs
Company hiring 25- 50 People a Year).PA (for factors named in point 4).
1) Cost of taking the Access: This is the First and6) Cost of Missed Excellent Employees: When a
Obvious Cost Involved. An Yearly Access ofCompany Negotiates and deals with the Candidates
Database of 1 Job Portal may cost approx Rs 2directly, there is a very strong possibility that a good
– 3 Lacs Per Annum with just 2 users. Biggercandidate turns back due to any kind of issues like
Companies with Big recruitment plans will surely haveego clash, non responsiveness of the organization for
to part with much more money.few days, direct negotiation etc. Besides how good it
2) Cost of Recruiters: Again assuming 2 People aremay look if I say I am an excellent Company and
Hired to work on these Portals for Internalemployer, the same is good if conveyed by a
recruitments, cost of each recruiter at Junior levelConsultant. These things can surely be avoided in
could be Rs 3.5- 6 Lacs PA (X2) (Assuming Salary ofcase an intermediary Placement Firm is there to
15- 25K PM, actual cost of each employee is atleastmitigate and simmer down all arising issues. Why
2- 3 times of their Salary if we include Phone Bills,Compromise on Quality when Consultants can provide
cost of infrastructure & Administrative Costs)you Ideal Candidates from Competitors or otherwise.
3) Cost of Delay in Recruitment: When a CompanyIts cost may be take as Rs 5 Lacs PA (Of the
starts depending on the Portals they spend lot ofbusiness that this employee could have generated or
time trying to fill Positions Internally, whatever maycosts he could have reduced or efficiency he may
be the delay. Delay can lead to lot of business losshave introduced and the cost of hiring an average
which may be in the form of lost sales, lostperformer).
contracts, opportunities lost etc. This loss can surely7) Cost of Lost Business or Lost Contract or
be avoided if a Search Firm is hired at the right time.Dysfunctioning of a department: Adding up points 3-
Headhunters/ Placement Agencies these days are6, Delays in Recruitment, High Attrition, Average/
extremely fast and utilize all means to fill in PositionsNon committed Employees are surely going to make
in the shortest time span. They may do headhuntingcompany loose some good existing or prospective
or referral or may search their own database. EvenClients or Contract or Business or may just lead to
with same Job Portal they can find much faster andCollapse of a department for its consequences to
better people owing to their vast experience in thefollow. Even if we loose a client of say business value
same. Lets take ths cost as Rs 5 Lac PA.Rs 1 Crore and Profit Margin of 20% we loose Rs 20
4) Cost of High Attrition: People who put theirLacs. Conservatively we take this cost at Rs 10 Lacs
Resumes on Job Portals are much more probable toPA.
get Job Offer every now and then (even if they8) Cost of Hiring through Consultants: Even if a
have recently joined your Organization.). Search FirmsCompany uses a Job Portal, it has to approach
on the other hand can provide lot of inactive JobConsultants for many of its Position especially at
seekers who have never floated their resumes onmiddle and senior management. Assuming they hire
Job Portals like Naukri of Monster. Even if 3 mid levelonly 6 people at say Rs 50K average salary, Cost is
people hired by you leave in say 3- 6 months ofRs 3 Lacs. This is an additional cost as most of the
being hired its cost may be in the tune of say Rs 7-above costs are already incurred before Consultant is
15 Lacs. (Total Salary Paid to 3 employees in sayreleased the Positions.
average 4 months 4X40,000X3 (as such short stay