How To Deal With The Unintentional Jerk Executive By Carl Robinson, Ph.d. © 2010

Difficult executives are the bane of their peers and ahave to cover the same territory over and over and
major drag on the energy of their bosses. There is ahelp them see the similarity between behaviors
particular type that I will call the "unintentional jerk"incidents, other people's interpretations of their
who has the best of intentions and firmly believesactions and the repercussions. Most have a hard time
that they are doing what is best for their companygeneralizing what they have learned from one
or team, yet leaves a trail of destruction as theysituation to something similar. Each incident/example
plow through the organization trying to achieve theirseems entirely unique. It takes significant patience on
goals. And, when confronted about their behavior,the part of his/her coach and key
they are shocked to hear that people are upset withstakeholders…especially the stakeholders because
them. They aren't necessarily passive aggressivethey will continue to experience problems as the
types (see my briefing titled: The Insidious Executive)coachee takes two steps forward and one step
because they aren't doing things behind people'sbackwards repeatedly.
back…they are blatantly pursuing their goals andYou might ask, "Why bother? Why not just fire the
running over people in the process.executive?" If the executive is someone who has
These executives are frequently the "true believer"risen through the ranks, you've invested a great deal
types, who want to do what's best but are deludedin their development already. If they are committed
by their own grandiosity and think their way is theto changing, and can make the changes, they are
best way. They think and act in a way that conveyslikely to be very grateful and even more committed
the message: "I know better than you so get out ofto your company's success. On the other hand, if the
my way because I'm doing what's best for theexecutive is fairly new (less than one year on the
company." They just can't put themselves in otherjob), it's probably better to cut your losses and cut
people's shoes and imagine how their actions arethem loose. Keep in mind that changing long-standing
impacting others or that they might not have abehavior takes time. Generally it takes a minimum of
license on brilliance. They are oblivious to howsix to twelve months to make the necessary
arrogant they appear.changes.
The good news is, however, that the unintentionalKey suggestions for working with and helping
jerk is often open to change, whereas, the true jerkunintentional jerks:
could care less. The challenge for a boss is to1. Don't assume ill intent or you'll set them up for
determine where their subordinate fits on the jerkfailure. They will never be able to overcome your
continuum. If the person truly is an unintentional jerk,prejudice.
then they may be able to adjust their attitude and2. Provide specific examples … in detail.
behavior if they work hard at it. True jerks aren't3. Explain the repercussions of their actions. Don't
worth the investment.assume they can connect the dots.
Several years ago, I was considered for a coaching4. Have them team up with someone who is more
gig to help a very narcissistic CTO. I knew it was"interpersonally adept" who can provide real time
unlikely that he would select me primarily because Iobservations and suggestions. A good role model.
told him that I would require him to acknowledge to5. Monitor their performance and reward successive
his peers that he had been difficult to work with andapproximations to the desired behavior. Don't just
he said he wouldn't do that. I told his boss that theywait to reward them when they hit the target
were wasting their money investing in him. Notbecause they won't do so on the first dozen
surprisingly, he ended up choosing someone lessattempts but they will inch closer if given useful
confrontational than me. I later learned that he quitfeedback and encouragement.
two months into the coaching process with the other6. If they don't make the attempt to change or
coach…again, no surprise.simply aren't able to learn after repeated coaching (6
Unlike that CTO, unintentional jerks feel remorse andmonths max) . . . move them out of a leadership role
want to get along with others but they need help.or out of the company. The cost to you and your
It's a tedious process because you have to provideemployees' morale will be too significant if you keep
real time examples, help the executive understandthe executive in a management position. Their
how their behavior impacts others, and then workso-called productivity/creativity will most likely not
with them to try new behaviors. Frequently, youoffset the toll they will take.