Why you should stop trying to delight your customers

Delighting customers does not build loyalty.  Reducingcustomers:
customers' effort does.1. Don't just resolve the current issue but head off
These were the findings from a large customerthe next one
service survey conducted by the Customer Contact2. Address the emotional side of customer
Council (CCC), and featured in the July edition of theinteractions
Harvard Business Review.  The survey's aim was to3. Minimise channel switching by boosting self serve
get answers to three questions:channel stickiness – 57% of complaints came
1. How important is customer service to loyalty?from customer trying to resolve issues online but
2. Which customer service activities increase loyalty,couldn't
and which don't?4. Use feedback from unhappy customers to
3. Can companies increase loyalty without raising theirenhance issue resolution rate
customer service operating costs?5. Empower the front line to deliver a low effort
After conducting structured interviews with customercustomer experience
service leaders and a study of more than 75,0003. Customer Effort Score (CES) tops the charts with
customers, the CCC uncovered three findings:the highest predictive power
1. Exceeding expectations during service interactionsIn the customer service environment, Customer
has negligible impact on customer loyaltySatisfaction (CSAT) is a weak predictor of customer
Of the 75,000 customers surveyed, they were moreloyalty.  Net Promoter Score (NPS) is slightly better.
interested in how well a company delivers on theirBy decreasing customer effort to purchase you can
most basic and/or vanilla promises rather than beingget increases in repurchase, increase spend and
dazzled and having their expectations exceeded. willingness to tell others about their experiences.
However, 89/100 customer service departmentThe survey asked customers to rate how much
heads had ‘to exceed customer expectations' aseffort they personally put forward to handle their
their main strategy.  This is not new.  As I wroterequest.  They were asked to rate on a scale of 1
back in June 2007, living by exceeding customers'(low effort to purchase) – 5 (high effort to
expectations doesn't add up and ends up costing uspurchase).  94% of participants reporting ‘low
more in the long term.effort' stated their intent to repurchase, 88% stated
2. Service organisations create loyal customerstheir intent to increase spend, and 1% stated their
primarily by reducing customer effortintention to speak negatively about the experience. 
In other words, helping customers solve theirVersus 81% reporting high effort stated their intent
problems quickly and easily – not by delightingto spread negative feedback about the experience.
them in service interactions.  Given these findings,Outcome: CCC advises that we should move from
we need to reframe around making the customerincreasing customer satisfaction to decreasing
experience easy.customer effort.
5 ways to lower the effort and make it easy forRemember everybody lives by selling something.